12 Comments
User's avatar
Kenny B.'s avatar

41% of staff on Minnesota Paid Family and Medical Leave? I think many taxpayers will find that surprising—and perhaps a little concerning. Thanks for bringing this to our attention, Terry!

It would be interesting to see the percentages from other city departments, along with some context about what that 41% represents. To me, that level of participation raises questions about sustainability and what safeguards are in place to prevent fraud or abuse. The program may need some fine-tuning going forward, before the tax burden pushes more people out of their homes.

Nick's avatar

I agree that this number is surprising and concerning, but do want to call out that Minnesota PFML is funded for 100% by payroll deductions (split between employee and employer). The program is definitely going to need fine-tuning as time goes on (still in its first year).

Laura murray's avatar

My understanding is the payroll deductions cover the employee pay....which leaves the employer on the hook for replacement costs. Which may be more costly than salaries of those on leave.

michele burns's avatar

With government employees the “employer” is the taxpayer. And even for non government businesses the consumer will end up paying more to cover the increased expense to businesses. As currently configured PFML is proving to be an unsustainable disaster.

Judy Longbottom's avatar

Thank you Terry for covering these important topics. As a small business owner in the area I can tell you that breakins, garbage to remove and graffiti costs have a huge negative impact to small businesses in the area and we are growing frustrated with this continued unanswered problem that we must manage and pay for ourselves.

LaDonna Meinecke's avatar

THis is not surprising at all. My friends and former colleagues who work in health care and nonprofit human services mention they are dealing with their respective departments having a similar percentage of employees out on leave.

Terry White's avatar

How can they function?

LaDonna Meinecke's avatar

Services to patients/clients are delayed. And the employees left behind are becoming burned out, increasing the risk that they will need extended time off.

Fink's avatar

Nice work on this topic Terry. Public comments are spot on. As such, it's disappointing and frustrating to know this is where we're at despite the state having included/involved chambers, employers and support from other states who had a program in-place before Minnesota to help design Minnesota's PMFL. Another example of how Minnesota's far-left leaderships' ideology and practices continue to plague Minnesota. A policy (or law) for the forthcoming additional tax burden should be put in-place to reduce an existing state tax by an equal amount of the future burden for purposes of accountability and other measures.

Laura murray's avatar

Some members of the city council insist on clinging to support of community safety spending, while not insisting on the same level of accountability they expect from the MPD. The hypocrisy is glaring. Taxpayers have funded five years of experiments, which is ample time to decide if these investments are worth the cost. Personally, it looks to me like we have a jobs program, which provides income to individuals but fails to produce measurable results and lacks basic oversight/financial controls.

The paid family leave program needs to evaluate the impact on MN employers, because it isn’t making us a desirable place to do business, and can create serious staffing issues. A couple of months ago, I read the program had paid out twice the amount taken in….which suggests serious sustainability issues with the current design.

Krisgronquist's avatar

So almost half of the staff are having a serious health condition or are "bonding, caring for a loved one, military family support, or safety issues"? That seems odd to me. I was an HR and Finance Director of nonprofits for several years. We had good benefits. I never had that high of a percentage of staff in such dire needs at one time.

Steven Brown's avatar

When the books close for the fiscal year and PFML is in the red, how long will it take for the state to raise the taxes employees and employers will have to pay? Not long, I’m sure.