The problem Terry has identified is that the Minneapolis DFL has an open structure that made it possible for the ideological borg to take it over. As long as the DSA element doesn't want to be dislodged and the state party is unwilling (or unable, I don't know how this works) to dislodge them, moderate DFLers don't have an option to reclaim the party.
If they're/you're/we're going to attempt something like that, I think the key is a name that says “We're non-leftist Democrats” not “We're independents.” Something like Minneapolis Democrats.
The MN DFL could have started by declaring the DSA to have a distinct, non-compatible platform, and not allow candidates to get a DFL endorsement if they hold or seek a DSA endorsement. But the MN DFL has refused to do that. Now that the DSA holds many positions within the DFL organizing units, and even within the DFL Senior Caucus, I don’t see how the ship can be righted, especially within Minneapolis.
I'm not convinced that a new party solves the problem. While there are a lot of moderate DFLers statewide, Minneapolis has A LOT of really far left residents. Look no further than last year's mayoral election, where Fateh only lost to Frey by 6 points.
That said, I very much support the idea of forcing the DSA crowd into their own party. Maybe our DSA crowd disappears on its own if America is able to fix the cultish disaster otherwise known as the GOP.
What perplexes me is that at the state house, the far-left legislators are able to whip the non-metro moderate Dems to fall in line behind their extreme policies, including shutting down a session for several weeks. These people are so ideologically different but vote together, because we only have two (dys)functional parties.
i am tired of voting for the lessor of the worst candidates. a third party would be great. maybe moderates from both parties could band together to form one. one can still dream ,right?
You have to wonder how a boob like Ken Martin got promoted to DNC chair. Maybe the Democrats, at both the state and national level, have affirmatively decided to capitulate to their left wing/DSA. There’s plenty of evidence to support this hypothesis when you look at how both state and national DFL/DNC party leaders and leading politicians have actually functioned over the past few election cycles—the actions they took or didn’t take, the people they supported, etc. They haven’t supported moderates since the Obama administration.
Long ago the DFL should have had the strategic smarts to not allow DSA - with its explicit goal to be a rival both to Republicans and Democrats - to enter their "big tent."
A similar idea was in play during the 2023 cycle: a coordinated, co-branded campaign by candidates in each ward, and it's most of them, where the DSA could be credibly opposed. This did not get legs, and consequently, in that cycle and the next one DSA overwhelmed regular Democrats, with their greatly superior organizing skills.
I'd favor an approach like this for 2029 over a "new" party, simply because it's not likely a strong brand for a new party could be built in such a short period. But a new-party movement could be worth a try, if enough money and the right coalition of community and civic leaders were brought to bear.
Bravo Terry. This may be one of your best pieces to date. You covered it all, and I 100% agree, Thank you! Forwarding it on.
* There is really no DFL, at least that is recognizable in Mpls and St Paul. Once the State DFL allowed the caucus and convention system in the Cities to be taken over by an organization/ party whose principals and platform do not, at all, align with the Democratic Party, they completely lost their way here.
After what I have witnessed in Mpls, beginning with the aggressive attempts by the DSA, in the community and on are OWN city council, to hard BLOCK the 3rd Precinct Police Station from coming back into the area, to the 18 neighborhoods that it served, going back years now, I could no longer refer to myself as a Democrat, or at least have it mean much here.
What happened with candidate Peterson is simply a logical and maneuvered strategy of the same, this anti police/ anti DFL platform, where one of the main goals is to disrupt and disable any/ all law enforcement agencies. Each and every vote by this faction involving policing and public safety, by the SIX CMs, along with their regular plus one ( although this Peterson vote took on a bizarre turn with alliances), is simply text book " death by a thousand cuts."
We need to do something NEW, and right about now, for the love of a city. ❣️
I agree with what everyone else has said about allowing the DSA to take over the city DFL. And make inroads at the legislature.
I attend the annual DFL dinners and find them heartening due to the big tent vibe. It always reminds me why I'm a Democrat. There is no DSA cant, just (usually) good speeches about the things we all care about.
Starting a 3rd party is a romantic notion. Look at the past attempts. Other than Jesse Ventura, a one-off, no Independent candidate has broken into double digits, and some were pretty solid and had name recognition.
Ken Martin said he was going to excise the DSA from the party. The State DFL committee said so too. But they never got around to it. If I remember correctly, the thinking then was that we needed their votes, but after the coming election (2024?)they'd get the boot. Never happened. And I'm not sure how they would do it anyway.
So here we are. We need to reform our existing party with all of its infrastructure and funding advantages, not try to build a new one. But as we've seen, the DSA progressives view the blue wave as a win for progressives and DSAers, while pragmatic Dems (like me) view it as a win for moderates, from Talarico to Hamilton to Ossoff . . . In fact, I think far more moderates won than DSAers. But good luck getting any DSAer to agree.
One thing that would really make a difference would be getting rid of the caucus system and going to a primary election instead. There are only about 5 states -- and Samoa -- that still use the caucuses. Who ever can pack a caucus is assured a place on the ballot, and of late that's been the DSA, at least at the city and county level. I'm told by the powers that be that it will never happen because it requires the legislature to make that change, and they all got there via the caucus system!
Ironically, when we moved here 50 years ago, it was feminists like Arvonne Fraser and Janet Shapiro and many others including me, who packed the caucuses so that women could have more power in the DFL. We succeeded. I also lived here briefly in 1972, and we anti-war activists packed the caucus to defeat HHH and nominate George McGovern instead. We succeeded and we know how that turned out!
The problem Terry has identified is that the Minneapolis DFL has an open structure that made it possible for the ideological borg to take it over. As long as the DSA element doesn't want to be dislodged and the state party is unwilling (or unable, I don't know how this works) to dislodge them, moderate DFLers don't have an option to reclaim the party.
If they're/you're/we're going to attempt something like that, I think the key is a name that says “We're non-leftist Democrats” not “We're independents.” Something like Minneapolis Democrats.
The MN DFL could have started by declaring the DSA to have a distinct, non-compatible platform, and not allow candidates to get a DFL endorsement if they hold or seek a DSA endorsement. But the MN DFL has refused to do that. Now that the DSA holds many positions within the DFL organizing units, and even within the DFL Senior Caucus, I don’t see how the ship can be righted, especially within Minneapolis.
I'm not convinced that a new party solves the problem. While there are a lot of moderate DFLers statewide, Minneapolis has A LOT of really far left residents. Look no further than last year's mayoral election, where Fateh only lost to Frey by 6 points.
That said, I very much support the idea of forcing the DSA crowd into their own party. Maybe our DSA crowd disappears on its own if America is able to fix the cultish disaster otherwise known as the GOP.
I agree more with Mike. I think moderate metro DFL voters have most in common with greater Minnesota DFL voters.
What perplexes me is that at the state house, the far-left legislators are able to whip the non-metro moderate Dems to fall in line behind their extreme policies, including shutting down a session for several weeks. These people are so ideologically different but vote together, because we only have two (dys)functional parties.
i am tired of voting for the lessor of the worst candidates. a third party would be great. maybe moderates from both parties could band together to form one. one can still dream ,right?
I think forcing the DSA into their own party is a great idea.
As the DFL state chair, Ken Martin should have helped do that years ago, and many called on him to do so. But alas.
You have to wonder how a boob like Ken Martin got promoted to DNC chair. Maybe the Democrats, at both the state and national level, have affirmatively decided to capitulate to their left wing/DSA. There’s plenty of evidence to support this hypothesis when you look at how both state and national DFL/DNC party leaders and leading politicians have actually functioned over the past few election cycles—the actions they took or didn’t take, the people they supported, etc. They haven’t supported moderates since the Obama administration.
“Much of their day to day activity appears to be building their social media follower counts.”
The irony seems to be lost on them that they are doing this with videos, photos, and posts hosted by…data centers.
Long ago the DFL should have had the strategic smarts to not allow DSA - with its explicit goal to be a rival both to Republicans and Democrats - to enter their "big tent."
A similar idea was in play during the 2023 cycle: a coordinated, co-branded campaign by candidates in each ward, and it's most of them, where the DSA could be credibly opposed. This did not get legs, and consequently, in that cycle and the next one DSA overwhelmed regular Democrats, with their greatly superior organizing skills.
I'd favor an approach like this for 2029 over a "new" party, simply because it's not likely a strong brand for a new party could be built in such a short period. But a new-party movement could be worth a try, if enough money and the right coalition of community and civic leaders were brought to bear.
I think they had the smarts, not the b -- um, spine.
Susan, I appreciate your understanding of anatomy.
Amy Klonuchar will be the head of the DFL in Minnesota starting in January. Maybe she will help us take back the party from the DSA.
Bravo Terry. This may be one of your best pieces to date. You covered it all, and I 100% agree, Thank you! Forwarding it on.
* There is really no DFL, at least that is recognizable in Mpls and St Paul. Once the State DFL allowed the caucus and convention system in the Cities to be taken over by an organization/ party whose principals and platform do not, at all, align with the Democratic Party, they completely lost their way here.
After what I have witnessed in Mpls, beginning with the aggressive attempts by the DSA, in the community and on are OWN city council, to hard BLOCK the 3rd Precinct Police Station from coming back into the area, to the 18 neighborhoods that it served, going back years now, I could no longer refer to myself as a Democrat, or at least have it mean much here.
What happened with candidate Peterson is simply a logical and maneuvered strategy of the same, this anti police/ anti DFL platform, where one of the main goals is to disrupt and disable any/ all law enforcement agencies. Each and every vote by this faction involving policing and public safety, by the SIX CMs, along with their regular plus one ( although this Peterson vote took on a bizarre turn with alliances), is simply text book " death by a thousand cuts."
We need to do something NEW, and right about now, for the love of a city. ❣️
I agree with what everyone else has said about allowing the DSA to take over the city DFL. And make inroads at the legislature.
I attend the annual DFL dinners and find them heartening due to the big tent vibe. It always reminds me why I'm a Democrat. There is no DSA cant, just (usually) good speeches about the things we all care about.
Starting a 3rd party is a romantic notion. Look at the past attempts. Other than Jesse Ventura, a one-off, no Independent candidate has broken into double digits, and some were pretty solid and had name recognition.
Ken Martin said he was going to excise the DSA from the party. The State DFL committee said so too. But they never got around to it. If I remember correctly, the thinking then was that we needed their votes, but after the coming election (2024?)they'd get the boot. Never happened. And I'm not sure how they would do it anyway.
So here we are. We need to reform our existing party with all of its infrastructure and funding advantages, not try to build a new one. But as we've seen, the DSA progressives view the blue wave as a win for progressives and DSAers, while pragmatic Dems (like me) view it as a win for moderates, from Talarico to Hamilton to Ossoff . . . In fact, I think far more moderates won than DSAers. But good luck getting any DSAer to agree.
One thing that would really make a difference would be getting rid of the caucus system and going to a primary election instead. There are only about 5 states -- and Samoa -- that still use the caucuses. Who ever can pack a caucus is assured a place on the ballot, and of late that's been the DSA, at least at the city and county level. I'm told by the powers that be that it will never happen because it requires the legislature to make that change, and they all got there via the caucus system!
Ironically, when we moved here 50 years ago, it was feminists like Arvonne Fraser and Janet Shapiro and many others including me, who packed the caucuses so that women could have more power in the DFL. We succeeded. I also lived here briefly in 1972, and we anti-war activists packed the caucus to defeat HHH and nominate George McGovern instead. We succeeded and we know how that turned out!