Better Minneapolis
Better Minneapolis Podcast
Minneapolis Moderates Need a New Party, Not Another PAC
0:00
-9:51

Minneapolis Moderates Need a New Party, Not Another PAC

Building a lasting alternative to the DFL/DSA means starting with a platform for 2029, not a candidate

Between headlines about trouble at the Federal Aviation Administration, we’ve been reading many commentators criticize the City Council after it rejected Mayor Jacob Frey’s nomination of interim Chief Bill Peterson to lead the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD). But this dysfunction didn’t start with Peterson. It’s built into how the council works.

Council members’ decisions have become overly parochial. Each member needs to satisfy only a few thousand of the most active voters in their ward, so the overall direction of the city falls much lower on their priority list. The result is a system that rewards conflict and punishes compromise.

Some believe Minneapolis is being run by a minority of candidates backed by the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) who won election in 2025. If you’re one of them, change isn’t going to come solely from complaining on social media and in the editorial pages of the Star Tribune. Sending checks to All of Mpls, a political action committee (PAC), and hoping for the best won’t work either. A new party is needed to represent the majority of moderate voters who are not aligned with DSA and who most want a city government that keeps basic services running well and provides stability.

This party must be built on a set of principles rather than loyalty to one candidate. If it consists only of a single candidate’s supporters, it breaks apart after each election and has to start over.

The time to begin forming this party is now, for the 2029 election and beyond. Building it won’t be easy. The 2028 presidential race will pull money and volunteers away from local efforts. But that campaign season could also give the new party time to settle on its platform before city races begin. The only organized political force in the city is the DFL and its DSA allies, and they are likely to sweep both the City Council and mayoral races without an alternative party to support candidates.

When Frey tried to change the city charter so the police chief would no longer need City Council approval, opponents filled the public comment meeting and the Charter Commission backed down. The showdown over choosing a police chief was predictable. Moderates have been out-organized by a passionate group of younger, hungrier DFL and DSA members who run the local party. They elected Cedrick Frazier as Hennepin County Attorney and helped Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan win the DFL primary. They share on social media how many doors they knocked. For many of them, political organizing meetings are a commitment similar to church.

May 2024, CM Vetaw spotted Inspector Charlie Adams on the Northside with CPS Bill Magnuson. Vetaw said Charlie Adams was her preferred pick for chief of police. (Photo: @MplsPDChief on X)

Bill Peterson’s Rejection Wasn’t About Him or Policing

We listened to hours of questions that Peterson answered and started to wonder whether any would be about policing. He was accused of being part of the Metro Gang Strike Force, which was shut down in May 2009 because of corruption and biased policing. When it turned out he wasn’t, council members moved on. They seemed less concerned about how he would stop the gang violence that continues to harm communities in Minneapolis and the surrounding area than about whether he was associated with that task force over 15 years ago.

Because the most active political organizers have decided the MPD is as racist now as it was two decades ago, responsibility for gang enforcement sits with the FBI, under President Donald Trump’s control. We need a task force to address gangs, and we’d much rather see a regional force do that work than an FBI under Trump. The focus on the law enforcement side of the problem means the underlying reasons Minneapolis is a breeding ground for gangs don’t get the attention they deserve. We’re busy figuring out exactly how racist the police force remains instead of prioritizing ways to build the kinds of communities that prevent gangs from forming.

There were a few questions about policing. Council Member Stevenson asked how Peterson would improve services, and Peterson responded, “I can tell you that over the course of my time being in the first precinct that I put an emphasis on treating every single victim as if they’re the only victim. . . Cases that are lower priority that don’t get investigated within some of the units . . . members of my team would take up those cases.”

Council Member Osman asked whether he would increase resources for investigating domestic violence. His answer showed his leadership qualities. He acknowledged that the MPD could do better, and he praised the work of Deputy Chief Adams, a competitor for the job. He met with the Domestic Violence Workgroup and asked them, “what is going well, what’s not going well.”

Time and again, he acknowledged shortcomings in the MPD and gave detailed answers about how he would address them as chief. However, he fell short of the council’s expectations for a leader who would purge racism from the department. In the end, the vote wasn’t about clearance rates, gun violence or domestic assault. It was about how vigorously he would root out racism.

As long as one racist police officer exists, Minneapolis politicians will keep circling this topic. At times it feels as though learning from the past and moving on isn’t an option, and the only option is to keep dredging up the past and relitigating who is to blame. That’s a problem, because Minneapolis must become a forward-looking city if it wants to attract businesses, workers and their families again. Minneapolis may want to move slowly, but society is changing faster every year. We can decide to keep data centers out of downtown office buildings, but we can’t change the fact that we need to keep renewing the city’s infrastructure if we want to benefit from technology rather than be run over by it.

This is where a new party could help. It could write a platform that recommends structural changes to the City Council. A city of our size does not need 13 full-time council members, each with at least two full-time policy aides. Much of their day to day activity appears to be building their social media follower counts. The current setup lets members who represent a small fraction of residents make demands that affect the entire city. We have a system in which the minority rules the majority.

What’s on the Horizon?

Minneapolis is a month away from its deadline to pass a 2027 budget. If the police chief vote is any indication, the budget fight will be messy, and it’s quite possible a similar standoff will mean the city enters the new year without an approved budget. We’re confident the council’s and mayor’s priorities will remain out of alignment. We expect three more years of standoffs and a lot of head-shaking from the public.

Several people have asked us who we think will run for mayor in 2029. That’s the wrong question. A better one is what platform could be the backbone of a new party that puts Minneapolis on a forward-looking path. Once that’s in place, the party can start vetting candidates to find one who represents its values. We’ll need someone who recognizes our historical shortcomings without letting them define our future.

Do we want to be a biotech hub like Boston, a magnet for AI companies like San Francisco or a finance center like New York? It isn’t clear what Minneapolis wants to be, other than a national focal point for social justice causes.

As for Peterson, if he stays on as interim chief, there doesn’t appear to be a fixed limit on how long he can serve. He could easily still be chief a year from now, because finding a candidate who can navigate the city’s politics will be a serious challenge.

If moderates want to change the direction of Minneapolis and bring stability to City Hall, they need to form a new party, not a new PAC.

Leave a comment

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?